Five Children Vanished After Mysterious Christmas Fire in 1945
The Sodder family fire remains one of America's most haunting unsolved cold cases
Published June 6, 2025
Case Details
Quick Facts
Classification:
Quick facts
On Christmas morning, December 25, 1945, the Sodder family in Fayetteville, West Virginia, was jolted awake by a fire at approximately 1:00–1:30 a.m. George Sodder, his wife Jennie, and four of their nine children managed to escape the burning house.
Five children were never seen again: Maurice (14), Martha (12), Louis (9), Jennie (8), and Betty (5). By the time firefighters arrived at 8:00 that morning, nothing remained but embers and ash.
No Human Remains Ever Found
The most deeply unsettling aspect of the case is that no human remains were ever recovered from the ruins. Despite this, authorities issued death certificates for all five children, listing the cause of death as "fire or asphyxiation."
Timeline
Fire at the Sodder family home
On Christmas morning around 1:00-1:30 a.m., a fire broke out at the family's home. George and Jennie Sodder and four children escaped, but five children disappeared without a trace. The fire department arrived at 8:00 a.m. and found only embers and ashes.
Suspicious findings at the scene
A ladder that normally leaned against the house was found pulled away to a nearby embankment. A bus driver reported having seen people throwing 'fireballs' at the house on Christmas Eve.
Authorities conclude it was an accident
A state police inspector concluded that the fire was caused by 'faulty electrical wiring'. Death certificates were issued for all five children with the cause listed as 'fire or suffocation', although no human remains were found.
Reported sightings of the children
Several reports of sightings of the five missing children between Fayetteville and Charleston, West Virginia. The family hired private detective C.C. Tinsley to investigate the case.
A state police inspector concluded that the fire had been caused by defective electrical wiring, and the incident was officially classified as an accident. The Sodder family refused to accept this conclusion.
Their suspicions were reinforced by physical evidence at the scene. A ladder that was normally kept leaning against the house was found dragged away to a nearby embankment. A bus driver also came forward to report that he had seen individuals throwing what appeared to be flaming objects at the house on Christmas Eve.
Reported Sightings After the Fire
In the aftermath of the fire, several reported missing children sightings of the five children emerged from locations between Fayetteville and Charleston, West Virginia. These reports gave George and Jennie Sodder reason to believe their children had survived.
The family hired private detective C.C. Tinsley to investigate the sightings and pursue answers that cold case investigation authorities had not provided.
Unsolved After 80 Years
The fate of the five Sodder children remains one of the most baffling unsolved American cold cases in American true crime history. No charges were ever filed, and no one was ever arrested in connection with the incident.
Officially, the fire is still recorded as an accident caused by faulty wiring. But the absence of any human remains, the moved ladder, and the subsequent sightings have led both the family and independent investigators to question that conclusion for decades.
Ask about this case
Answers from KrimiNyt's coverage onlyFollow this case
Get an email when a new documentary, podcast or book about Five Children Vanished After Mysterious Christmas Fire in 1945 appears, or when a verdict is reached.