Case File

Ghent Altarpiece Theft 1934: The Just Judges Panel

How a Belgian insurance agent's 1934 crime sparked decades of mystery—and Nazi conspiracy theories

Published June 6, 2025

A weathered art museum display stand, empty, with a plaque reading "'The Just Judges'," symbolizing Belgium's enduring mystery of the missing Ghent Altarpiece panel, surrounded by visitors peering at the vacant space
EVIDENCE

Quick Facts

Perpetrator(s)No convicted perpetrator – primary suspect: Arsène Goedertier (stockbroker, Wetteren)
Victim(s)Saint Bavo's Cathedral (Sint-Baafskathedraal), Ghent, and the Ghent Altarpiece as a work of art
Crime sceneGhent, Belgium
Date of crimeThe night of 11 April 1934
Type of crimeTheft of cultural heritage / extortion

The case in brief

The theft of the Just Judges panel from the Ghent Altarpiece took place on the night of 10 April 1934 at St Bavo's Cathedral in Ghent, Belgium: thieves removed the panel, the lower left panel of the altarpiece painted by Jan and Hubert van Eyck, together with the reverse side of a second panel, St John the Baptist. The art theft was never solved. Suspicion fell on the banker Arsène Goedertier, who died on 25 November 1934 without revealing where the Just Judges were hidden. Nobody was ever charged or tried, and the panel has never been recovered.

The theft

On the morning of 11 April 1934 the sexton found that the lock of the Vijd chapel had been forced and that the Just Judges and John the Baptist panels were gone. A note in French was left on the frame: "Taken from Germany by the Treaty of Versailles". The iron hinges that had held the wings had been removed. The panels had been sawn in half lengthwise in 1894, when they were in the Kaiser Friedrich Museum in Berlin so that both sides could be displayed, which made it easier to steal them. Police found no fingerprints or other traces.

The ransom letters

On 30 April 1934, nineteen days after the theft, the Bishop of Ghent, Coppieters, received a letter demanding one million Belgian francs; otherwise the panels would be destroyed. It was signed with the initials D.U.A. The bishop was willing to pay but did not receive permission from the public prosecutor and the Minister of Justice, so he ostensibly cooperated and kept negotiating. As a gesture of goodwill the sender returned the John the Baptist panel via a luggage receipt for the Brussels-North station. Later a priest in Antwerp, Father Henri Meulepas, was told to hand over the ransom; on 14 June 1934 a taxi driver collected a parcel that contained only 25,000 francs, not the one million demanded. Further angry letters followed until 1 October 1934.

Timeline

11 April 1934

'The Just Judges' panel stolen from the cathedral

On the night of 11 April 1934, the panel disappears from Saint Bavo's Cathedral in Ghent. The investigation finds no usable fingerprints or trace evidence.

30 April 1934

Extortion letter received by the bishops

On 30 April 1934, the bishops receive a letter written in French demanding 1 million Belgian francs for the panel's return.

1 January 1934

Arsène Goedertier named prime suspect

Stockbroker Arsène Goedertier from Wetteren becomes the prime suspect in the search. On his deathbed he reportedly states that he knows the panel's hiding place, but dies without disclosing it.

The deathbed statement

In November 1934 Arsène Goedertier, 57, the owner of a small bank office in Wetteren, suffered a heart attack shortly after a speech in Dendermonde and died on 25 November 1934. Before his death he told his lawyer that he alone knew where the original panel was hidden. In the folder he named, police found copies of the thirteen ransom letters to the bishop, but no trace of the panel. The lawyer reportedly told the police only about a month later. Police concluded that Goedertier had been the thief, though it is speculated that he did not act alone.

The search and the copy

Several people have claimed to know the panel's whereabouts, and extensive searches have been made, including an X-ray survey of the whole cathedral to a depth of ten metres. The panel has not been found; some believe it has been destroyed. A Ghent police detective is still assigned to the case. In 1945 the restorer Jef Van der Veken replaced the missing panel with a copy.

Status today

The case remains unsolved. The sources do not say what happened to the panel, and this article does not speculate.

Ask about this case

Answers from KrimiNyt's coverage only

Follow this case

Get an email when a new documentary, podcast or book about Ghent Altarpiece Theft 1934: The Just Judges Panel appears, or when a verdict is reached.

Share this post: