
About This Episode
What is this episode about?
The episode "Who's Afraid of LaDonna Humphrey Part 19: Yes Way, José" from PRETEND covers the unexpected return of host Javier Leiva to this long-running series after his name began surfacing across subreddits, a podcast, a Substack, and even an AI-generated country album released on his birthday. Much of that attention traces back to David McClam, described as LaDonna Humphrey's biggest cheerleader.
The episode shifts from internet noise to serious allegations when two of McClam's adult sons reach out to share what they say it was like growing up with him. Leiva walks through public records tied to McClam, including a 2010 arrest, alongside the sons' accounts.
Leiva also details his attempt to get a response from McClam, who denied the allegations, stated "No one in this house has been abused," and threatened retaliation against his sons. McClam reportedly told Leiva he would release CPS and school records if the episode aired and claimed it would end his son's career. McClam then published his own episode claiming he could "single-handedly right now destroy everything" his son had built, and said his website was designed so abuse accusations would surface when searching his son's name.
This installment continues the Humphrey Part series, with this chapter specifically framed around the Yes Way subtitle marking its focus on McClam's conduct and response.
Hosts and release
Javier Leiva hosts, reports, and produces PRETEND, an investigative true crime podcast examining the psychology and real stories behind scammers, fraudsters, and their victims. New episodes release weekly on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, YouTube, and Overcast. This episode runs 48 minutes and was released November 17, 2026.


