About This Episode
What is this episode about?
The episode "Episode 20: 'The Most Perfect Daughter'" from Natalie McNally Murder: YouTuber on Trial features an interview with Natalie McNally's parents, Bernie and Noel, who sit down with Kelly Bonner to talk about their daughter, whom they describe as their 'perfect daughter'. They speak about the deception their family suffered at the hands of their daughter's killer. The episode notes that Stephen McCullagh was convicted of the murder of Natalie McNally earlier that week, and that he will be sentenced the following month.
The conversation, also referenced under the title The Most Perfect Daughter, centers on the family's experience in the aftermath of the trial rather than the courtroom proceedings themselves. It offers a personal account from those closest to Natalie, reflecting on who she was and what they endured as the case against her killer unfolded.
A warning accompanies the episode noting that it features content some listeners may find distressing.
Hosts and release
The hosts are Kelly Bonner and Chris Buckler, who tell the story of the BBC podcast series covering the trial of a man accused of the murder of Natalie McNally in Lurgan in 2022. This particular episode, released on 26 March 2026 and running 25 minutes, is available on BBC Sounds. It marks a shift in the series from courtroom reporting to a direct, personal interview with Natalie's parents in the days following the conviction.
