CounterClock: The Pelley Family Murders

CounterClock: The Pelley Family Murders investigates the tragic case from Lakeville, Indiana, where Pastor Bob Pelley, his wife Dawn, and her two daughters Janel and Jolene were found murdered in their home on April 30, 1989.

Bob's son Jeff Pelley, a teenager at the time, became the prime suspect, but the case remained unsolved for years. It wasn't until 2002 that Jeff Pelley was arrested and later convicted of the four murders, though he has consistently maintained his innocence.

The podcast examines the evidence in the case with a critical eye, questioning the timeline presented by the prosecution during the trial. Host Delia D'Ambra digs deep into the police investigation, interviews key figures connected to the case, and examines whether there is reasonable doubt about Jeff Pelley's guilt.

The CounterClock series is known for its thorough research and nuanced approach to complex criminal cases. This season focuses in particular on how the passage of time and limited forensic technology in the 1980s affected the investigation, as well as the consequences this has had for everyone involved over three decades.