Case File

Brittany Smith Case: Alabama Stand Your Ground, 2018

St. Clair County, Alabama, 2019 — prosecuted homicide case involving a domestic-violence self-defense claim

🇺🇸 American

Published June 2, 2026

The Brittany Smith Case — Alabama Self-Defense Homicide
EVIDENCE

Quick Facts

Perpetrator(s)Brittany Smith
Victim(s)Todd Smith
Crime sceneStevenson, Jackson County, Alabama, USA
Date of crimeJanuary 16, 2018
Type of crimeMurder

The case in brief

The Brittany Smith case concerns the killing of Joshua "Todd" Smith in Brittany Smith's home in Stevenson, Jackson County, Alabama, in January 2018, which she said was self-defense after he had raped and assaulted her. In February 2020 Jackson County Circuit Court Judge Jennifer Holt denied her immunity under Alabama's Stand Your Ground law. In October 2020 Smith pleaded guilty to murder and was given a 20-year sentence, split between prison and house arrest. The two were not related.

The crime

Todd Smith was an old acquaintance of Brittany Smith, a former teenage friend who had recently reconnected with her on social media and was staying at her home in Alabama. According to Oxygen's reporting, Smith said that on 15 January 2018 he strangled and raped her; she was later described as having 33 wounds on her body. Her brother, Chris McCallie, armed with a .22 revolver, came to her home, and a physical fight followed between him and Todd Smith. Brittany Smith then got hold of her brother's firearm and fired several shots at Todd Smith. She had been charged with first-degree murder.

The immunity ruling

The defence asked the court to dismiss the charge under Alabama's Stand Your Ground law. After a hearing in January 2020, Judge Holt wrote in a 19-page order on Monday 3 February 2020 that Smith "did not credibly demonstrate that she reasonably believed it was necessary for her to use deadly force". The judge found that the 33 wounds were consistent with physical assault but that Smith had had many opportunities to seek protection, that Todd Smith was unarmed while she held a revolver, and that she had given inconsistent accounts, including in a 911 call. The defence appealed to the Alabama appellate courts; according to Oxygen, they upheld the ruling.

Timeline

16 January 2018

Brittany Smith shoots and kills Todd Smith

On January 16, 2018, Brittany Smith shoots and kills Todd Smith in her home in Stevenson, Jackson County, Alabama. She claims self-defense following an alleged rape and assault.

16 January 2018

Brittany Smith charged in connection with Todd Smith's death

Authorities open an investigation and file charges against Brittany Smith following the incident in Stevenson.

1 January 2019

Judge Holt denies Stand Your Ground immunity

Jackson County Circuit Court Judge Jenifer Holt denies Brittany Smith's request for immunity under Alabama's Stand Your Ground law following a hearing.

1 January 2020

Appeals to Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals and Alabama Supreme Court fail

The defense appeals the Stand Your Ground ruling to both higher courts in Alabama, but neither appeal succeeds.

1 October 2020

Brittany Smith pleads guilty to murder

At Jackson County Circuit Court, Brittany Smith enters a guilty plea for murder. The case is thus concluded without a jury verdict. She receives a sentence of 20 years.

1 January 2022

Release and subsequent return to custody

Brittany Smith is released from Alabama State Prison, but is returned to custody following reported violations of her parole conditions.

The plea

Smith, 32, pleaded guilty to murder in October 2020, shortly before the trial was to begin. She was sentenced to 20 years, split between prison and house arrest, with credit for time served in county jail; her lawyer said she would be released from prison in roughly seven months and serve the remainder confined at home. She had faced life in prison if convicted at trial. Her lawyer called the district attorney's offer "generous" but said he had thought the defence had a good case.

Status today

Reports on the case at the time of the plea covered it as a debate about how the justice system treats women who kill alleged abusers. The sources we have read do not document what has happened since the sentencing, so this article makes no statement about Smith's release or any later developments.

Media coverage

TV series

  • State of Alabama vs. Brittany Smith(2026)

Ask about this case

Answers from KrimiNyt's coverage only

Follow this case

Get an email when a new documentary, podcast or book about Brittany Smith Case: Alabama Stand Your Ground, 2018 appears, or when a verdict is reached.

Share this post: