trial by media

When public opinion convicts before the courts do — a phenomenon, not a legal status.

Trial by media describes a situation in which a suspect or charged person is treated in media coverage and public debate as if their guilt has already been established, even though no legally binding judgment exists. In Danish law the concept is not part of criminal law or criminal procedure, and it does not appear as an official procedural status in legislation. It is a linguistic and journalistic expression describing a social and reputational phenomenon, not a legal condition.

Danish law distinguishes precisely between the formal stages of a criminal case: a person may be a suspect, charged (sigtet) or indicted (tiltalt), and only upon conviction is the question of guilt legally settled. The Danish Court Administration (Domstolsstyrelsen) emphasises this distinction in its public communication, precisely because the designations carry specific legal consequences. None of these stages coincides with being "tried by media", which refers solely to public perception.

In true crime contexts — including cases such as the killing of Meredith Kercher in Perugia in 2007 — the term is used for the phenomenon whereby the intensity and framing of media coverage can create a widespread conviction of a person's guilt long before the trial has concluded. Amanda Knox is a classic example: much of the international press portrayed her as guilty within the first months after the killing, while the Italian courts alternated for years between conviction and acquittal.

The concept carries an implicit criticism of the press's power to shape public opinion in criminal cases. A person subjected to trial by media may suffer serious consequences for their social life, career and mental health — consequences that are not necessarily undone by a subsequent acquittal, because public perception is rarely corrected to the same extent as the original condemnation spread.

The phenomenon touches on fundamental principles such as the presumption of innocence, which in Danish law follows from the structure of the Administration of Justice Act (retsplejeloven) and from Article 6(2) of the European Convention on Human Rights. These principles apply in court — but not automatically in public discourse, which is the core of the concept.