not liable verdict
US civil verdict finding the defendant not legally responsible for the claim
A 'not liable verdict' is, in US civil law, a decision — rendered by a jury or a judge — that the defendant is not legally responsible for the claim brought by the plaintiff. The term belongs exclusively to the civil justice system in the United States and must not be confused with a criminal acquittal ('not guilty'). In a civil case, the basic opposition is between 'liable' and 'not liable'.
The plaintiff bears the burden of proof and must establish the claim under the civil standard, which in most cases is 'preponderance of the evidence' — that is, that it is more likely than not that the defendant is responsible. If that burden is not met, the court returns a not liable verdict. In concrete terms, such a decision means that no damages are awarded on the claim in question. The plaintiff receives no compensation, and the defendant bears no civil liability for the alleged loss or harm.
In the Kevin Spacey case before a federal court in New York in 2022, the jury reached precisely this result: Spacey was found 'not liable' on the plaintiff's civil claim of sexual abuse. The case illustrates how a person can be cleared in a civil case independently of any criminal proceedings — and vice versa.
It is important to stress that a not liable verdict is not a general exoneration of the defendant, but only a finding that the plaintiff did not meet the burden of proof in the specific civil case. Other claims, other plaintiffs or criminal proceedings may in principle run in parallel or follow afterwards.
