Keith Wolf: The Evidence Behind the Cellar Doors — Dark Matter Moms, podcast-episode
Dark Matter Moms
•
November 16, 2026

Keith Wolf: The Evidence Behind the Cellar Doors

Dark Matter Moms covers the Wisconsin basement killing of Keith Wolf and the forensic trail to a suspect

0:000:00

About This Episode

HostSam and Sarah
Podcast SeriesDark Matter Moms
Duration61 minutes

What is this episode about?

The episode "Keith Wolf: The Evidence Behind the Cellar Doors" from Dark Matter Moms covers the fatal shooting of Keith Wolf, who was killed in the basement of his home in Wisconsin's Town of Leeds on September 27, 2019, while his wife and daughter were upstairs.

The episode follows the investigation into his death, focusing on the physical evidence recovered at the scene: DNA found on the cellar doors, unusually large shoe impressions, and a shell casing. These pieces of evidence eventually pointed investigators toward Jason Kijewski. The hosts trace how forensic genealogy helped identify him as a suspect, and the episode includes excerpts from Kijewski's recorded interview with investigators.

A content warning is attached to the episode for its discussion of homicide and gun violence. Sources for the episode include Columbia County Circuit Court records, including the criminal complaint, Wisconsin Circuit Court Access (CCAP), and recorded law enforcement interviews provided by the Columbia County Sheriff's Office.

Hosts and release

Dark Matter Moms is a true crime podcast covering cases from Wisconsin, hosted by two mothers who go through court documents and police reports. The show has 17 episodes, with its most recent installment released in September 2026. Sam and Sarah host the show, and this episode runs 61 minutes, released on November 16, 2026.

Share this post:

Follow this podcast

Get an email when a new episode of Dark Matter Moms: Wisconsin True Crime from Two Mothers is released.