Operation Tempura: When a Corruption Probe Became the Scandal
A decade-long investigation in the Cayman Islands descended into chaos, destroying careers and costing millions—without a single prosecution
Published June 6, 2025

Quick Facts
In September 2007, authorities in the Cayman Islands launched what was supposed to be a straightforward anti-corruption operation. Police Commissioner Stuart Kernohan had initiated Operation Tempura after receiving allegations that senior officers were engaged in bribery and misconduct. Few could have predicted that this investigation would run for two years, destroy multiple careers, and ultimately collapse without securing a single conviction.
The operation began with a narrow focus: examining alleged corruption between a newspaper publisher and a police officer. But as is often the case with sweeping investigations into institutional misconduct, the scope expanded dramatically. The probe eventually ensnared the very leadership overseeing it, creating a toxic cycle of allegations, suspensions, and legal battles that paralyzed parts of the Caribbean territory's justice system.
Among the casualties was Police Commissioner Stuart Kernohan, who was suspended in March 2008 and dismissed later that year after the investigation he had requested. Other senior officers were arrested on suspicion of perverting the course of justice and conspiracy. But the investigation's reach extended beyond the police force. A sitting judge was arrested during the probe—a rare and shocking development in any jurisdiction. A practicing attorney also lost their license, though the decision was later reversed.
Timeline
Operation Tempura launched
In September 2007, the anti-corruption investigation into the Royal Cayman Islands Police Service (RCIPS) in the Cayman Islands is launched.
Rudolph Dixon arrested and charged
Former deputy police commissioner Rudolph (Rudi) Dixon is arrested and charged as part of the course of the investigation. Exact date not verified beyond the year.
Justice Alexander Henderson arrested
Retired Grand Court judge Justice Alexander Henderson is arrested. The arrest is subsequently ruled unlawful; he receives over £1 million in compensation.
RCIPS Commissioner Stuart Kernohan suspended
Police Commissioner Stuart Kernohan is suspended in the wake of the investigation and subsequently dismissed. Exact date not verified beyond the investigation period.
Operation Tempura ends – no convictions
In October 2009, the investigation is concluded. None of those charged are criminally convicted. Total public costs exceed US$10 million.
The investigation was led by a Scotland Yard team under former Detective Chief Superintendent Martin Bridger. The involvement of foreign investigators, while intended to ensure impartiality, instead seemed to add layers of complexity and contention. Questions later emerged about the conduct of the investigators themselves, undermining public confidence in the entire operation.
For a jurisdiction the size of the Cayman Islands—a territory of roughly 70,000 people—Operation Tempura became an all-consuming institutional crisis. The financial cost ballooned into the millions. The reputational damage extended across the government, courts, and police service. Citizens watched as institutions meant to uphold justice appeared to tear themselves apart.
Years passed with little resolution. Arrests were made, careers were destroyed, and legal fees mounted. But as time went on, the once-promising investigation lost momentum. Cases stalled. The evidence that had seemed so damning in 2007 and 2008 began to look less clear-cut. Political pressure mounted to bring the ordeal to an end.
In October 2009, two years after it began, Operation Tempura was halted without a single successful prosecution. Separately, in November 2017 the case against Martin Bridger, the officer who had led the probe, was closed with no charges.
What remained was wreckage. The judge whose lives had been upended, Alexander Henderson, had his arrest ruled illegal and was later awarded more than £1 million in damages. But compensation cannot restore a career interrupted or a reputation permanently scarred. For the Cayman Islands, Operation Tempura became a painful lesson in how investigations into institutional corruption, if poorly managed and overseen, can become corrupting forces themselves.
The case has since become a reference point in discussions about investigative oversight and institutional accountability in small jurisdictions. It illustrates a paradox common in corruption probes: the machinery created to root out misconduct can, if unchecked, create its own injustices. The operation that was meant to restore faith in Cayman's institutions instead deepened public doubt about how power operates in small territories dependent on external support and oversight.
For observers of Caribbean governance, Operation Tempura stands as a reminder that the cure for institutional corruption must itself be carefully administered—or risk becoming the disease it seeks to treat.
Ask about this case
Answers from KrimiNyt's coverage onlyFollow this case
Get an email when a new documentary, podcast or book about Operation Tempura: When a Corruption Probe Became the Scandal appears, or when a verdict is reached.


