wrongful convictions

A judgment resting on an erroneous basis, correctable by reopening in Denmark

A wrongful conviction is a judgment in which the court has reached an incorrect result — typically a conviction of a person who is in fact innocent, or an acquittal despite sufficient guilt. Under Danish law the concept is not defined in legislation as an independent legal category, but it is used in case law, legal literature and public debate as a collective term for judgments resting on an erroneous basis.

Errors in a judgment can arise in several ways: through incorrect assessment of evidence, through procedural errors during the investigation or the trial, through false or mistaken witness statements, through deficient expert opinions, or through mistakes made by defence counsel or the prosecution. In serious cases, a combination of several such errors can lead to an innocent person being convicted.

The primary legal mechanism for correcting wrongful convictions in Denmark is the reopening of criminal cases, governed by the rules on this in the Danish Administration of Justice Act (retsplejeloven). A case may be reopened in favour of the convicted person if new information or evidence emerges that would probably have led to a different outcome. A request for reopening is submitted to the Special Court of Indictment and Revision (Den Særlige Klageret) under retsplejeloven § 979.

Wrongful convictions differ from judgments overturned on appeal, in that an appeal is the ordinary system of review, while reopening is an extraordinary remedy that presupposes new circumstances. A judgment set aside on appeal because of procedural errors need not necessarily be described as a wrongful conviction in the sense that the substantive result was incorrect.