temporary insanity
A US legal claim of insanity confined to the moment of the offence, not chronic.
Temporary insanity is, in US criminal law, a claim that the defendant was temporarily insane or mentally incapable of understanding what they were doing, or that the act was unlawful, at the very moment of the offence — but that this condition was short-lived rather than chronic. The concept belongs to American law and has no direct parallel in Danish legislation.
There is no single uniform federal rule on the matter. Temporary insanity is rather a popular label for a time-limited application of the broader insanity defense, which is recognised to varying degrees across the American states. Not all states accept the defense, and the criteria for what qualifies as insanity in the legal sense vary.
The core of the defense is the element of time: the defendant claims to have been mentally incapable of acting responsibly precisely at the decisive moment, but not necessarily before or after. This distinguishes it from an ordinary insanity defense, where the mental disorder is typically of a more lasting character.
In the case against Lorena Bobbitt in 1994, the defense used a variant of this argument. Bobbitt was acquitted after the jury found that at the time of the act she was suffering from a brief dissociative state resulting from prolonged violence and abuse — a condition that deprived her of the capacity to act with reason and responsibility. The case is one of the best-known examples of how the temporary insanity argument is used in practice.
Critics of the defense point out that an alleged short-lived mental state is difficult to verify after the fact, and that this opens the door to abuse. Supporters argue conversely that the justice system should take account of extreme states of psychological strain that may genuinely remove mental accountability in a delimited situation.
