second-degree murder
US legal term for an intentional killing committed without premeditation
Second-degree murder is, in US law, an intentional killing that does not meet the requirements for first-degree murder. The concept is defined in federal law under 18 U.S.C. § 1111, which briefly states that any murder not classified as first-degree murder constitutes second-degree murder. It is exclusively an American legal concept and has no direct parallel in Danish criminal law.
The central legal distinction between first- and second-degree murder is the degree of advance planning. First-degree murder requires premeditation — that is, the perpetrator deliberately and calmly planned the killing beforehand. Second-degree murder, by contrast, is committed intentionally but spontaneously or in the heat of the moment, without such cold-blooded deliberation being provable. Although premeditation is not required, second-degree murder still requires the legal element known as malice aforethought — a conscious and malicious intention to kill or cause serious harm. It is this element that separates second-degree murder from manslaughter.
In the case against Sally McNeil, who in 1995 shot and killed her husband Ray McNeil with a shotgun on Valentine's Day, she was sentenced in California to 19 years to life precisely for second-degree murder. The prosecution argued that the killing was intentional, but that there was insufficient evidence of advance planning to raise the charge to first-degree murder. McNeil herself claimed self-defence.
The penalty for second-degree murder under federal law may, pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 1111, be imprisonment for any term of years or for life. In practice, sentences vary considerably from state to state, as most homicide cases are prosecuted under state law rather than federal law.
