DNA technology
Methods that turn biological traces from a crime scene into criminal evidence
DNA technology is, in a criminal law context, a collective term for the technical methods that make biological traces from a crime scene usable as an investigative tool and as evidence in criminal cases. The core of the method is that an individual-specific DNA profile can be extracted from biological material — for example blood, hair or semen — and subsequently compared with other profiles in order to establish or rule out a person's presence at the crime scene.
The classic application consists of comparing DNA traces from a crime scene with profiles in the police DNA register. In Denmark, such registers are administered on the basis of the legislation on police activity, and registration generally presupposes that a person has been charged with or convicted of a criminal offence. A positive correspondence — a so-called match — can constitute a central item of evidence in a criminal case, but is always assessed in conjunction with the other evidence in the case.
A newer and more far-reaching method is genetic genealogy, in which an unidentified DNA trace is compared with profiles in civilian genealogy databases. The method can reveal biological relatives of the person who left the trace and thereby lead investigators to a specific individual. In Denmark, this method is subject to separate regulation, as the police may only use genetic genealogy under certain conditions laid down in legislation.
The case concerning the killing of Birgitte Tengs illustrates both the significance and the limitations of DNA technology. The case, which took place in Norway in 1995, remained unsolved for decades partly because the technology at the time was more primitive, and partly because the DNA traces found did not for many years match any registered person. Only with technological advances and renewed investigation did the DNA evidence become decisive for solving the case.
In legal terms, DNA evidence is subject to the general principles governing evidence in criminal cases: the evidence must have been lawfully obtained, and its weight is determined by the court on the basis of an overall assessment of the evidence. A DNA match is expressed statistically as the probability that the trace originates from a random other person in the population, and this statistical context is central to the legal assessment of the evidence.
