A podcast that masters fascination and emotions in crimes
How can a podcast balance on the edge between fascination and emotions while exploring some of the world’s most tragic crimes? This is the art that Once Upon A Crime has perfected. Created and hosted by Esther Ludlow, who combines journalism with her background as a psychologist, this podcast has captivated listeners with in-depth true crime stories since its debut in June 2016. The podcast presents a range of remarkable criminal cases—from children involved in crimes to historical mysterious events—done in a way that's both enlightening and captivating. Independently produced, without backing from major media companies, it's distributed for free on platforms like Apple Podcasts and Spotify, while Patreon subscribers get access to exclusive content.
Thorough research and ethical challenges under scrutiny
Ludlow's dedication to thorough research and powerful storytelling sets a high standard. Her episodes unravel both the events of the crimes and the social factors that paved the way for the tragedies. In her coverage of the Mary Bell case, the girl who at 11 committed murder on two younger boys, she sheds light on her traumatic upbringing and the subsequent media coverage. In another episode, she covers the famous Elizabeth Smart abduction, revealing the complexities in the psychological aspects of both the victim and the perpetrator, including how religious fanaticism became a tool for the nightmare. Despite the work being praised for its accuracy and nuance, criticism of loud ad breaks and ethical sensitivity regarding cases with living victims has been a challenge. Ludlow addresses these issues by anonymizing sources and working with investigators, which strengthens the podcast’s integrity despite these challenges.
Reopening cases and cultural influence through podcasts
Once Upon A Crime has not only enjoyed a significant influx of listeners but also impacted real life, as certain episodes have led to the reopening of old cases. One example is new information in the Charles Starkweather case, which prompted Nebraska police to reopen the investigation. This cultural gravity is further emphasized by the podcast’s nomination for True Crime Podcast of the Year at the British Podcast Awards 2023. Even alongside true crime giants like Making a Murderer and Serial, Once Upon A Crime continues to deliver a unique voice that encourages reflection on the complex facets of justice and its often uneven distribution in society.