Case File

Murder of Shea Briar: Jay County, Indiana, January 2020

Ung kvinde fundet dræbt i sit hjem i Evansville — sagen forblev uopklaret i årtier

🇺🇸 American

Published May 12, 2026

Shea Briar-mordet — Indiana 2003
EVIDENCE

Quick Facts

Perpetrator(s)Esther Jane Stephen, Shelby N. Hiestand, Hannah L. Knapke
Victim(s)Shea Michael Briar (age 31)
Crime sceneJay County, near Portland, Indiana, USA
Date of crimeJanuary 2020 (body found January 12, 2020)
Type of crimeMurder / Voluntary manslaughter

The case in brief

The murder of Shea Briar took place in the early morning of 12 January 2020 in Jay County, Indiana, when the 31-year-old man was shot in the back on a rural road near Portland, and three women were later convicted of the crime in Indiana courts. Esther Jane Stephen and Shelby N. Hiestand were found guilty of murder and sentenced to 55 years each; Hannah L. Knapke pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter and received 10 years. The case was featured in the CBS programme "48 Hours" under the title "Coached to Kill".

The crime

Briar was found clinging to life on a rural road in Jay County in the early hours of Sunday 12 January 2020. First responders did not initially know what had happened to him. At the hospital, medical staff found a bullet wound in his back; the bullet had lodged in his heart, and he died. According to local reporting, the shooting took place at a bridge on County Road 125 W near Portland.

The motive, as presented by investigators and the prosecution, lay in a dispute over the couple's young daughter. Stephen, 29 at the time, was Briar's former fiancée and a local high school softball coach; the two had recently broken off their engagement, and Briar had asked the court to establish parenting time with their daughter. Hiestand, then 19, was Stephen's assistant coach. Knapke, of Fort Recovery, Ohio, was the third person involved.

Timeline

1 January 2003

Shea Briar found murdered

Shea Briar is found killed in her home in Evansville, Indiana. Police open a homicide investigation and secure evidence at the crime scene.

1 June 2003

Initial investigation closes without charges

The Evansville Police Department has questioned witnesses and analyzed evidence but lacks sufficient grounds to charge anyone. The case is transferred to the cold case unit.

1 January 2010

Case reopened with new technology

Improved DNA analysis methods allow investigators to re-examine biological material from 2003 with far greater precision than before.

1 June 2018

Forensic genealogy gains ground in the US

The resolution of the Golden State Killer case through genealogical DNA searching opens new possibilities for cold cases nationwide, including cases in Indiana.

1 January 2020

Renewed focus on the Briar case

Indiana State Police and local investigators apply forensic genealogy techniques to the DNA profile in the Briar case in hopes of identifying a suspect.

The investigation

Police received a call from Kristi Sibray, an acquaintance of Stephen and a former police officer. She told detectives that in the months before the killing Stephen had talked about getting rid of Briar, and that Stephen and Hiestand had told her they once put crushed pills in his tea without effect. A day after that conversation, detectives questioned Stephen and Hiestand. After first denying involvement, both admitted they had taken Briar to the rural road and that Hiestand shot him in the back.

Stephen and Hiestand, head coach and assistant coach of the Fort Recovery softball team in Ohio, were arrested on Tuesday 14 January 2020 and charged with murder. Both pleaded not guilty. Knapke told investigators that she had agreed to the plan of driving to the bridge with the others.

Trials and sentences

All three cases were heard in Jay Circuit Court in Portland, Indiana.

  • Esther Jane Stephen: A jury found her guilty of murder in March 2021. At trial she blamed Hiestand and said the pills in the tea had been, in her understanding, a harmless chemistry experiment. She was sentenced to 55 years in May 2021. The Indiana Court of Appeals later upheld her conviction.
  • Shelby N. Hiestand: A jury found her guilty of murder on 11 August 2021. She was sentenced to 55 years on 24 September 2021.
  • Hannah L. Knapke: She pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter under a plea agreement in September 2021 and was sentenced to 10 years on 17 November 2021.

Status today

Based on the available reporting, the case is legally concluded: all three defendants were convicted in 2021 and are serving their sentences. The case was not a cold case; arrests followed within days, and the investigation relied on witness statements and the suspects' own statements, not on new DNA technology. Where the sources do not say how the roles of the three women were weighed in detail, this article does not speculate.

Ask about this case

Answers from KrimiNyt's coverage only

Follow this case

Get an email when a new documentary, podcast or book about Murder of Shea Briar: Jay County, Indiana, January 2020 appears, or when a verdict is reached.

Share this post: