Case File

Scott Lee Kimball: Colorado Serial Killer, Ex-FBI Informant

Colorado, USA, 2003-2004: four murders, 70 years in prison in 2009

🇺🇸 American

Published May 12, 2026

Scott Kimball — Seriemorderen fra Colorado
EVIDENCE

Quick Facts

Perpetrator(s)Scott Lee Kimball
Victim(s)Terry Kimball, Jennifer Marcum, Kaysi McLeod, LeAnn Emry
Crime sceneColorado and surrounding areas; centered in Boulder County
Date of crimeJanuary 2003 – August 2004
Type of crimeMurder (four victims)

The case in brief

Scott Lee Kimball, born on 21 September 1966 in Boulder County, is a Colorado con man and forger and a convicted serial killer who killed at least four people between January 2003 and August 2004. Two of his victims were close to him: his stepdaughter and his uncle. For the first year of the killings he worked as an FBI informant. In October 2009 he pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder, admitting responsibility for all four deaths, and was sentenced to 70 years in prison, to run concurrently with his sentences for fraud. Investigators strongly suspect him in as many as 21 other unsolved killings, but he has not been charged in them.

The four victims

LeAnn Emry, 24, was the girlfriend of a prison inmate Kimball knew. After a week of travel in which the two stole checks worth about $15,000, she checked out of a hotel in Grand Junction, Colorado, on 29 January. According to Kimball's later account he shot her in the head in a canyon in Utah. Her car was found near Moab, Utah, and Kimball later led investigators to her body.

Jennifer Marcum, 25, a dancer and mother of a young son, was the girlfriend of another inmate. She disappeared in February 2003; her car was left at Denver International Airport on 18 February. Her body has never been found.

Timeline

1 January 2003

Offense period begins

From January 2003, the period begins in which Scott Lee Kimball, according to the formal verdict, killed his four victims in and around Colorado.

31 August 2004

Offense period ends

In August 2004, the confirmed offense period ends. By this time, Kimball has killed Terry Kimball, Jennifer Marcum, Kaysi McLeod and LeAnn Emry.

8 October 2009

Verdict handed down: 70 years in prison

On October 8, 2009, the Boulder County District Court sentences Scott Lee Kimball to 70 years in prison after he pleads guilty to two counts of second-degree murder and admits responsibility for all four killings.

3 March 2011

Kimball publicly acknowledges full responsibility

In March 2011, UPI reports that Kimball publicly maintains full responsibility for the four murders.

19 September 2018

Case retold on Dateline NBC

In September 2018, The Denver Post covers a Dateline NBC segment on the case, which again puts focus on Kimball's crimes and his background as an FBI informant.

Kaysi McLeod, 19, the daughter of Kimball's partner Lori McLeod, disappeared in August 2003 while Kimball was away on what he called a hunting trip. He planted evidence suggesting that she was still alive and later married her mother. Hunters found a skull in Routt National Forest near Walden in 2007; a DNA test confirmed that it was Kaysi's.

Terry Kimball, his uncle, came from Alabama in 2004 to help care for a child. After he disappeared, Scott used his credit card and wrote bad checks on his account. Terry's mummified body was found near Vail Pass in 2009.

The FBI informant

Kimball convinced FBI agents in federal prison that he would work for them as an informant, and was never brought to trial on an earlier charge in Spokane. Almost nothing he told the bureau helped prosecute other crimes, and much of it proved false. His fraud also helped hide the murders: he created evidence that victims were still alive and used their bank accounts and credit cards. The case greatly embarrassed the FBI, and the agent who handled Kimball was disciplined.

How he was caught

An investigation into a 2006 check fraud scheme led police to the murders. Detective Gary Thatcher interviewed Lori McLeod, who told him about her daughter's disappearance. Kimball fled to California and was arrested on 14 March after a car chase near Mecca. Prosecutors offered him a deal: plead guilty to fraud and reveal where the bodies were, and he would face one count of second-degree murder. He showed investigators the bodies of LeAnn Emry and of his uncle, but could not or would not locate Jennifer Marcum's body. Because he had failed to meet the terms, the deal fell through and he faced murder charges in all four cases.

Sentence and status

Kimball was sentenced to 70 years in October 2009 after pleading guilty to two counts of second-degree murder and admitting responsibility for all four deaths. He later also pleaded guilty to attempted escape from state prison. He is serving his sentence in federal prison, at the United States Penitentiary Florence High in Colorado. The question of how the FBI handled its informant remains part of the case.

Media coverage

TV series

  • 48 Hours Mystery: Scott Kimball, the Informant Turned Serial Killer(2026)

Podcasts

  • Between The Madness Ep. 9: Deal With The Devil – Scott Kimball(2026)

Ask about this case

Answers from KrimiNyt's coverage only

Follow this case

Get an email when a new documentary, podcast or book about Scott Lee Kimball: Colorado Serial Killer, Ex-FBI Informant appears, or when a verdict is reached.

Share this post: